St. Timothy Sunday, 2025
Isaiah 42:1-7
Psalm 30:1-5
2 Timothy 1:1–8
John 10:1–10
In the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. Amen.
Today we celebrate St. Timothy Sunday. Our “patronal feast,” as it is called. And we have good reason to celebrate our 189 years of ministry in Massillon, and beyond. This parish has done some amazing things, and we have a proud history of helping our neighbors. From setting up trade schools in the basement, to building a chapel for our black neighbors after the Civil War. Over the centuries we have fed people, and educated people, and entertained people, and been good neighbors for a long time. And I know we will continue to do even more in the future.
We also have some dark periods in our parish history.
In 1851, at a Christmas Eve service, a young girl named Abby was accused of “spirit rapping,” because noises were heard during the priest’s sermon. She was charged with disturbing a religious service, and an actual trial was held in Cleveland, which was covered by the local media for several days. The judge dismissed the case for lack of evidence. And life went on.
In 1873, Fr. Wallace Probasco came to St. Timothy’s. In the earliest versions of our parish history, his red-headed wife is disparagingly described as drawing attraction from the the older men of the parish, and riding her horse around town like a “common hussy.” But that was probably just the anger talking, since she refused to visit her priest husband as he died of smallpox, for fear it might damage her delicate complexion. More recent editions of the parish history are a little kinder to her. And life went on.
In 1877, Fr. Robert Dunbar Brooke took over at St. Timothy’s, and he lasted just 8 years. As our parish history puts it, “An unsubstantiated story says that after a secret vestry meeting he was asked to resign. A Southern Democrat [right after the Civil War] he had alienated some of the congregation by his political views.” And life went on.
The point of my telling you these stories is, we can celebrate our history, while also acknowledging where we’ve gone off the rails. And life has gone on.
And this week, as we celebrate our parish history, many people are celebrating the inauguration of our new president. Nationwide, 49% of the people voted for him. In Ohio, 55% of the people voted for him. In Stark County, 61% of the people voted for him. Which means, 61% of our voting neighbors wanted the things that are starting to happen, and will happen in the years ahead. On Monday, as fires continued to rage in southern California, we withdrew from the Paris Climate Agreement, joining an elite group of four countries, which now includes Iran, Libya, Yemen and us. As we have clawed our way back from Covid, and the threat of avian flu and other diseases continues to grow, we have now withdrawn from the World Health Organization, and paused funding for medical conferences and cancer research.
Lots of other things happened this week as well, such as pardoning people who assaulted and killed police officers at the Capitol on January 6th, because we back the blue, and support law and order. And, closest to me, the Federal Government now says that trans people do not exist. As the proud parent of trans person I can tell you this one is patently false. Trans people do exist, and you have met one, and eaten meals with one, and heard one sing in our choir. But 61% of my neighbors wanted this denial of my child’s existence, and so here we are. Welcome to Stark County Fr. George.
You might be among the 61% who are celebrating the inauguration of the new president, and I sure hope the price of eggs finally does come down. But some of us are sad, and angry, and worried for our children. And not just for our own children. When ICE comes back again to raid the Freshmark plant—which they most certainly will—I worry about what happens to the children who come home from school to find their parents are suddenly gone. Seriously. What happens to them? Those are real kids, who live ten blocks away from us, no matter the price of the eggs they pack into the cartons we buy at Giant Eagle. So yeah. Some of us are sad, and angry, and worried for our children. But 61% of the people in Stark County wanted exactly this.
Now I know some of you are thinking, “Hey, Fr. George promised not to preach politics from the pulpit.” And, yes, I did promise that. Because you’d hate to follow in the footsteps of the Southern Democrat Fr. Robert Dunbar Brooke and be run out of town on a rail. But I’m not talking about politics or elections; I’m talking about the results of politics and elections. I’m not telling you who to vote for, or my opinions on legislation. I’m just telling you about the real-world consequences in the real world we live in because 61% of the people told us they wanted this world.
And this seems as good a time as any to tell you that on Thursday, someone called the church office and left a l-o-n-g and rambling message about how disgusted he was by what a Bishop in another Diocese said to the president during her sermon, explaining how she could not possibly know that people are frightened right now, and how he would never join our church, and that the Episcopal Church leadership is absent because they have their heads stuck up a “woke hole.” Left that message. On our church voicemail. A faith community 400 miles away from that sermon. We’re in for quite a ride the next four years, I can tell you that.
But there is nothing political about what I’m saying. I haven’t mentioned anyone’s name or political party. I am just reminding you that we are heading into a period of great suffering for the people around us, including people you know and love. People who are going to need protecting, and support, and allies. And for the next four years, some of us are going to be sad, and angry, and worried, while knowing that 61% of the people we run into in the grocery store wanted exactly this.
And I’m also telling you where I am, as your priest. Like it or not, you have a priest who—barring some outside intervention—is going to be sad, and angry, and worried for some time to come. But I am still your priest, no matter who you voted for, and no matter who you support in the political realm. So see? I’m not preaching politics after all! I’m just asking you to care. Asking you to care about people who are going to suffer. A lot.
But at the same time, we are still here celebrating St. Timothy Sunday and preparing for our Annual Meeting. Our gospel street preacher is probably outside right now with his plastic bullhorn getting ready to terrorize us after the service. (Which is all the more incentive for you to stick around for the luncheon and Annual Meeting, so you don’t have to hear him call you a sodomite as you walk to your car today.) But he’s allowed to be out there. The First Amendment supports his freedom to do that—for those who still believe in the Constitution And he doesn’t actually disrupt our services, like Abby’s alleged spirit rapping did back in 1851.
We’ve been through a lot these past 189 years. And God willing, we will be through a lot for many years to come. But I can’t help but think we are at an inflection point as a parish, while living in a country that is also at an inflection point. Are we willing to honestly look at who we are and who we want to be? Are we willing to put aside partisan talking points and things we see online to honestly talk to each other? Or are we more inclined to take the easy path. Be reflexively angry at someone who disagrees with us. To shut out those who get their news from a different source. To reject those of a different tribe. And that goes in both directions, believe me.
St. Timothy’s has held together through an actual Civil War. Through two World Wars. Through panics and depressions and presidential assassinations and civil unrest, and more than one pandemic. And yet here we are. Battered, and damaged, in an aging building that never stops leaking. But here we are. We can do this because we have done this.
Some of us are really hopeful right now, but some of us are sad, and angry, and worried for our children. But we are in this together. And that’s the most important thing. Together. Let’s keep talking. Let’s keep loving our neighbors as ourselves. And let’s keep trusting God to guide us into the future. A future where one day, by the grace of God, not any single one of us will have to wake up feeling sad, and angry, and worried for our children. As our own state motto says, “with God all things are possible.” May God make it so. May God make it so, and may God continue to bless St. Timothy’s Episcopal Church.
Amen